![]()
Photo: The United States Capitol building. Image by Noclip, public domain via Wikimedia Commons.
House Democrats on Thursday unveiled legislation that would put a 10-year expiration date on final deportation orders and give longtime immigrants a pathway to a green card, in a direct challenge to the Trump administration's hardline immigration enforcement.
The bill, titled the Protect Our Neighbors Act, will be introduced by California Democratic Representative Lateefah Simon, ABC News reported. It is co-sponsored by California Democratic Representatives John Garamendi, Zoe Lofgren and Juan Vargas.
Under the proposal, a final order of removal would expire 10 years after it was issued for people who have remained continuously in the United States and have not been convicted of a crime. Under current law, such orders never expire — a person can live in the country for decades under an order that could be enforced at any moment.
What the bill would do
A final order of removal is issued by an immigration judge or immigration authorities and becomes final once administrative appeals are exhausted or the deadline to appeal passes. It gives Immigration and Customs Enforcement the legal authority to deport a person, even if deportation does not happen immediately.
The bill would allow an immigration judge to renew an expired order, but only if it was established by "clear and convincing evidence" that there was significant cause for the delay in executing the order unrelated to administrative or funding delays, and that renewal is in the public interest based on new evidence.
Crucially, the legislation would also create a pathway to lawful permanent residency — a green card — for people whose qualifying removal orders have expired.
Former acting ICE Director Todd Lyons told lawmakers in February that about 1.6 million people in the United States had final orders of deportation. The proposal would affect a significant share of that population: people who have built lives in American communities over many years despite unresolved orders.
Inspired by a grandmother's deportation
The bill was inspired in part by the case of Harjit Kaur, a 73-year-old grandmother who had lived in the San Francisco Bay Area for about three decades before being deported to India. Kaur was detained during a routine ICE check-in in September 2025 and deported under a removal order issued by an immigration judge in 2005 — even though she had been checking in regularly with ICE and had authorization to work legally.
Simon told ABC News she was optimistic about bipartisan support for the bill and said she has spoken to Democratic leadership about it.
Long odds now, new life in January
The legislation faces long odds in the current Congress. It is unlikely to be taken up before the end of the year during the lame-duck session, ABC News reported. But it could re-emerge next year, after Democrats take control of both houses of Congress in January following their midterm wins and are empowered to send legislation to the floor for votes.
President Donald Trump told CBS News' "60 Minutes" that he would "love to do something on immigration" with Democrats, a remark that has raised hopes of a deal on legal status for some longtime workers. That openness does not guarantee he would back this particular measure, and the bill's critics have already framed it as a reward for evading deportation orders.
The proposal lands in the middle of an immigration crackdown that has defined Trump's second term. The Department of Homeland Security and ICE have stepped up action against people with final orders of removal, including deportations to third countries, and a federal judge in Colorado ruled on Wednesday that ICE had "made a mockery of court orders" by immediately re-arresting people after judges ordered their release.
For now, the Protect Our Neighbors Act is a statement of where Democrats intend to take immigration policy when they hold the gavel in January. Whether it becomes law will depend on whether the party can hold together a coalition — and whether the president's stated openness to a deal survives contact with a bill his allies are already calling amnesty.
Sources: ABC News, Business Standard