Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on Saturday that Kyiv has not yet seen written commitments for the NATO-style security guarantees proposed by US envoy Jared Kushner — and warned that words alone will not be enough.
"[NATO's] Article 5 is collective defense. What remains unclear for Ukraine is who exactly this collective would consist of, how it would defend us, and whether it would be prepared to repel the aggressor," Zelenskyy told journalists.
"The answers must not simply be words, however eloquently they may sound, that 'of course, nobody will abandon you'. This must be on paper. So far, I have not seen such commitments on paper."
![]()
Photo: Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. Photo by Vinnytsia Oblast State Administration (CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons).
The Kushner Proposal
Kushner, President Donald Trump's son-in-law and special envoy, has discussed giving Ukraine NATO membership if it hands over the territory it still holds in the eastern Donbas region to Russia, The Wall Street Journal reported this week, citing people familiar with the matter.
According to the report, Kushner and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff have raised the idea in several conversations with European officials in recent months — most recently last week at a military airfield in Dublin, where the US envoys met Zelenskyy, his adviser Rustem Umerov and several European national security advisers.
The United States has raised two possible scenarios, the Journal reported. In the first, Ukraine would give up the territory it still holds in Donbas in exchange for full NATO membership. In the second, the war would be frozen along the current front line, leaving part of Donbas in Ukrainian hands, and Ukraine would receive security guarantees through an international treaty with the US and possibly European allies.
"Comfortable" With Article 5
Speaking alongside European leaders in Berlin on Thursday, Kushner said Moscow had warmed to the idea of NATO-style protections for Ukraine.
"I think we've got the Russians comfortable with that concept where any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5," Kushner said, referring to the clause in NATO's treaty that treats an attack on one member as an attack on all.
A US official told the New York Post that the goal of any settlement would be to get Ukraine "as close to NATO as possible without the brand," and that Moscow has signaled it is "OK" with Kyiv receiving considerations similar to Articles 4 and 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty.
The Kremlin, however, has firmly rejected any positioning of Western military personnel inside Ukraine.
Europe Divided
European leaders are split on the idea. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has told aides Ukraine would not join NATO in his lifetime, according to the Journal report, and German hosts in Berlin were unwilling to pursue the issue. French President Emmanuel Macron, by contrast, said after the Berlin meeting that it was time to discuss Ukraine's membership.
Zelenskyy said NATO membership remains Ukraine's preferred security guarantee, and stressed that any guarantees must last far beyond the current US administration.
"We need guarantees not for two years, but preferably forever. At least for decades," he said. "We have to guarantee Ukraine, our citizens first and foremost, and all of Europe that security guarantees for Ukraine will be strong not only for these two years while President Trump is the President of the United States, but beyond that as well."
A Peace Push Under Fire
The diplomatic push comes amid intense fighting. Hours after Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin issued a peace declaration following their trilateral meeting in Shenzhen, Russia launched one of the largest missile and drone attacks of the war on Ukraine, hitting electricity facilities and killing at least eight people.
The White House wants a Ukraine-Russia peace deal by early January, according to the Financial Times, but the gap between what Kyiv will accept on paper and what Moscow will tolerate remains wide — and, as Zelenskyy made clear on Saturday, Kyiv is still waiting to see the American offer written down.
Sources: The Wall Street Journal, EA WorldView, Ukrinform, New York Post.