After Midterm Landslide, Democrats Split Over Working With Trump or Fighting Him
![]()
Photo: Noclip / Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
Fresh from a midterm election landslide, Democrats gathered in Denver this week united on one goal — delivering voters relief from high costs — but sharply split over how to do it, what their victory means, and how combative they should be toward President Donald Trump.
The party's first major gathering since its November 3 rout of Republicans offered an early glimpse of the battle to define its future, as prospective 2028 presidential candidates and senior leaders debated how to turn electoral success into a governing agenda while navigating long-standing ideological and generational divides.
Democrats are projected to hold at least 255 seats to Republicans' 169 in the U.S. House, with 12 contests still undecided. In the Senate, the breakdown will be at least 55-44, with Democrats possibly gaining one more seat in Alaska when vote-counting is completed.
Work With Trump or Fight Him?
One of the most striking debates in Denver centered on how to govern with Trump still in the White House, holding veto power for two more years.
James Talarico, the first Democrat elected to the U.S. Senate from Texas since 1988, urged Democrats to work with Trump. "We should make the final two years of his presidency the most productive of any presidency in American history," Talarico said, drawing tepid applause. "We're tired of being pitted against each other."
He found an ally in Iowa Governor-elect Rob Sand, who said he encouraged Democrats at campaign events to applaud Republicans and that partisan warfare will not deliver results. "The only way we're going to fix that is by fixing it together," Sand said.
Minutes later, U.S. Representative Jamie Raskin of Maryland and Eric Holder, who was attorney general in the Obama administration, largely rejected accommodation with Trump. Raskin, expected to become chairman of the House Judiciary Committee in January and oversee investigations of Trump next year, said the Republican Party had become an authoritarian cult of personality.
"We're going to reassert all of the powers of Congress that have been surrendered and abdicated by the MAGA Congress to King Trump," Raskin said. "We're going to enforce the Constitution against him."
Holder warned Democrats against pursuing bipartisanship. "If we retreat into caution, if we operate out of fear, if we take refuge in the niceties of the old Washington and seek approval from those who have been and are actively dismantling our institutions, we will fail."
Competing Visions for Governing
Almost everyone who spoke at the conference agreed the party's top priority was lowering costs and improving life for working families. It was a theme echoed by New York Representative Hakeem Jeffries, set to become U.S. House Speaker, and several prospective 2028 presidential candidates, including Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg, and California Representative Ro Khanna.
But splits emerged over how to achieve that. Khanna, a progressive and potential presidential candidate, urged Democrats to stop chasing the political center and embrace a bolder agenda, including universal healthcare, a wealth tax, a $25 federal minimum wage, deep Pentagon cuts and abolishing U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
By contrast, Shapiro, a moderate and another potential 2028 contender, argued the party should move beyond ideological litmus tests, saying voters "don't give a damn" about such debates and care instead about whether Democrats can deliver results.
Jeffries, a moderate, was heckled by a group of protesters who accused him of being too timid to deliver change and called for a House leader who embraced a more populist progressive agenda. Khanna and Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen, another progressive who this week challenged more centrist Senator Chuck Schumer of New York for the party's top leadership job in the Senate, called for populist, government-funded economic solutions.
Don't Blow It
There was a collective anxiety among the speakers that the party might squander one of the biggest victories it has achieved in a generation. Many speakers described the win not as an enduring mandate, but rather a temporary opportunity voters had given them to fix the country's problems.
Arizona Senator Ruben Gallego, another potential presidential contender, noted that many Hispanic voters who voted for Trump in 2024 backed Democrats this month. "It was not, though, a love letter to the Democratic Party," Gallego said. "It is a short-term loan that we need to keep paying, or we will lose it."
The breadth of the Democratic victories has allowed moderates and progressives to argue that voters have endorsed their vision for the party's future. "It's to be expected that there will be a big debate because the Democratic victory was so broad it swept in centrists, southern Democrats and more progressive and left-wing Democrats," Democratic strategist Elaine Kamarck told Reuters.
Trump retains significant executive authority to block much of the Democrats' agenda, complicating the party's efforts to lower costs — the central issue voters gave Democrats control of Congress to fix. The conference, hosted by Majority Democrats, a group that advocates for younger party leaders and against left-wing activism, offered a forum for the jockeying now underway as Democrats debate what lessons to draw from their midterm win and begin the search for a 2028 White House standard-bearer.
Sources: Reuters; reporting from the Majority Democrats conference in Denver.