Trump Asks Supreme Court to Curb Judges' Power to Block Federal Rules Nationwide
![]()
Photo: Joe (Jovianeye) / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
President Donald Trump's administration has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to curb a longstanding power of federal judges to throw out government agency actions nationwide, in another legal push to insulate presidential policies from broad court challenges.
An appeal filed by Trump's Justice Department, now pending before the Supreme Court, urges the justices to curtail the longstanding ability of judges to halt the actions of federal agencies that hold immense power to carry out the Republican president's policy priorities.
According to the administration, courts should not be able to shut down an agency's regulation entirely, instead limiting any relief granted only to the specific plaintiffs in a given case.
Extending Last Year's Ruling
When Trump's administration convinced the Supreme Court last year to restrict the ability of federal judges to block his actions nationwide — a major boost to his power — the ruling left untouched a separate tool that some of them have used to stymie presidential policies. Now Trump is taking aim at that tool as well.
At the administration's behest, the Supreme Court in June 2025 clamped down on nationwide — or "universal" — injunctions that can block the government from enforcing a policy against anyone, not just the challengers who sued. Judges had increasingly deployed these orders in a wide array of cases against Trump, including those alleging violations of the U.S. Constitution.
The administration wants to extend the constraints that the 2025 ruling placed on injunctions to similar orders judges may issue to invalidate policies under the Administrative Procedure Act, or APA, the 1946 law that governs the way federal agencies operate, including how regulations are implemented.
Aditya Bamzai, a University of Virginia expert in administrative law, said a win for Trump in the case could let the U.S. government continue to enforce rules broadly on all but the plaintiffs in a given case, potentially for years as litigation plays out, even after judges have deemed them unlawful. Siding with Trump "would give more flexibility to the executive branch," Bamzai said. "Whether you like or dislike that flexibility can perhaps depend on whether you like or dislike a particular administration's policies."
The Case Behind the Appeal
The new appeal arises from a challenge by Texas medical providers to federal rules implementing a statute Trump signed into law during his first term in office to limit unexpected medical bills. The Supreme Court is expected to consider whether to take up the case early next year.
The regulation at issue sought to constrain "surprise" medical bills from hospitals and health providers outside a patient's health insurance network. A Texas association of medical doctors, air-ambulance providers, and other plaintiffs argued that the regulation violated the APA and artificially deflated their insurance reimbursement rates.
The New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals voided parts of the rule nationwide in August on the grounds of an APA violation. The Trump administration's appeal is not challenging the 5th Circuit's decision about the regulation's legality. Rather, it seeks to prevent the judicial use of the APA to stop a policy nationwide.
The administration contends, as it did in its case against universal injunctions, that the APA does not grant courts such sweeping authority, instead allowing them to block a regulation's enforcement at most against the specific plaintiffs who challenged it in a particular case. The Supreme Court "should return the lower courts to their proper role under the APA," the Justice Department said in its filing.
A Tool at the Center of Hundreds of Lawsuits
Judges and appeals courts have long claimed the power under the APA to "hold unlawful and set aside" agency regulations they deem illegal, invalidating them on a universal basis. Since Trump returned to office, his administration has faced hundreds of lawsuits challenging his aggressive moves to limit immigration, pursue mass deportation, end diversity initiatives and curtail transgender rights, among other actions, that have pushed the boundaries of presidential authority.
Various plaintiffs have sued by invoking the APA in numerous cases, including to fight the termination of humanitarian legal status for hundreds of thousands of migrants living in the United States, major cuts to research grants related to racial minorities or LGBT people, and the use of a mass voter verification system to conduct sweeping citizenship checks.
Proponents, including numerous state governments that regularly sue the federal government, say this judicial tool is an essential bulwark against executive overreach. Others say the APA is important to maintain uniform regulations applied equally to everyone.
"When an agency adopts a rule that has been held to be unlawful, sometimes the only sensible solution is to wipe it off the books," said law professor Ronald Levin of Washington University in St. Louis. "You can't have a food-safety rule that applies only to some. You can't have an auto-safety manufacturing rule that applies only to some manufacturers. It's a tool they (judges) should have — not one they should use in every case, but ... there are some cases where the need for it is compelling."
If the Supreme Court agrees with the administration, Levin said, "it would take longer for challengers to get unlawful regulations removed from the books."
Trump's administration may face pushback from a broad array of opponents on its new effort. Texas, Florida and some other states, mostly Republican-led, had urged the 5th Circuit not to "neuter" the APA's effectiveness, calling the law important for maintaining the balance of power between states and the federal government. "The APA is a critical tool ... to curb federal overreach and incursions into state sovereignty by executive-branch agencies," these states said.
Though Democratic President Joe Biden's administration also had asked the Supreme Court to rein in universal injunctions as lower courts hindered many of his key initiatives, the 2025 ruling proved to be a major victory for Trump. The justices issued a separate 6-3 ruling last June on the legality of Trump's birthright citizenship policy, rejecting it as unconstitutional.
Sources: Reuters; The Straits Times.